John Truscott normally writes articles for us in series but, for a change, is currently contributing a number of one-offs. So far he has covered ‘Worrying websites’, ‘Global giving’, ‘Changing churches’, ‘Eco-education’ and ‘Difficult decisions’. This time he provides practical ideas for administrative support for Ministers of small churches.
From time to time I am asked how you can appoint a Church Administrator in a really small church, or a group of small churches, where such a formal post seems out of scale.
This might be a rural benefice, circuit or equivalent where there is only one stipendiary (or salaried) Minister shared between half a dozen churches. Or perhaps an inner-city or estate church with a small congregation where the idea of a Parish Administrator would sound rather too grand.
I am going to assume there is no church office as such, or only a rudimentary one designed more as a work-station than the hub of church life. This does not have to be the case as it is possible to form a large enough group of small churches to have a central office. Some villages or group ministries are able to do this. But that usually assumes a team of Ministers and, for the purposes of this article, I have a solo Minister more in mind.
So here are seven ways to think, all expressed in the format ‘A rather than B’.
1: An Assistant rather than an Administrator
First of all, the model of a ‘Church or Parish Administrator’ based in the ‘Church Office’ is not appropriate here. Instead of a job title for someone who serves, primarily, the church, think instead of a title for someone who serves, primarily, the Minister.
Drop the ‘Administrator’ title as this leads to unhelpful thinking. Think instead of an ‘Assistant’ for the Minister – you may prefer that title to ‘PA’ or ‘EA’.
I realise there is a danger of making the whole structure Minister-centric, but that is where things are at in many small churches, especially in rural and inner-city or estate areas. So the idea here is to have someone working alongside the Minister, freeing them up for their proper role by handling as much as possible of the admin that comes their way. In a small rural or urban church there is still a great deal of admin that lands on the Minister’s desk and is in danger of stifling what their real role should be.
Much of this would be handled in a larger church by a paid Administrator and by a range of professional members of the congregation with the required skills and experience. But you need a different model for the very small church.
2: A Gofer rather than a Secretary
But an Assistant does not have to be solely concerned with secretarial work at a desk. What they need to be doing is work that the Minister does not have to do themselves and which takes time and perhaps bother.
One example might be phoning round a group of people to sort out a meeting date and time. Yes, you might want to use a digital tool such as a doodle poll but in the churches we have in mind you will have people without internet access so that may not work. It can be tedious ringing round and finding people are out when sorting out a meeting. An Assistant can gain satisfaction by taking that off the Minister to free them for more appropriate work.
Once you think in terms of an Assistant for the Minister rather than a Church Administrator, other tasks come to mind. A busy Minister who is single may find the weekly Tesco shop to take up valuable time – why not ask the Assistant to do it once they know likes and dislikes clearly? Or, let them at least sort out the internet order for the groceries. Why not ask the Assistant to pick up the kids from school on a day when the Minister has an important meeting or a funeral? Or sort out the mess in the study?
So, get away from the idea of a Secretary, and think instead of a Gofer – someone who is utterly reliable and who can run errands, produce print and devise innovative, digital solutions to specific tasks that take the Minister’s time.
3: Responsibilities rather than tasks
But that does not mean anyone can do this job – quite the opposite. The biggest mistake I see in churches that I have in mind here is when someone with limited ability offers to help and is accepted with gratitude. Be careful! They may have little IT experience, be unable to drive a car, work slowly and make mistakes, or fail to understand how the Minister ticks.
Because you are a small church you set your sights low on ability – but this is wrong-headed thinking! Such appointments may end up causing more frustration than solution, and minimal benefit because of the constant need to supervise.
It is vital that the person selected for this kind of role can take real responsibility and be admired for their wisdom, efficiency and engagement with the Minister. You want someone to whom you can confidently delegate issues that require tact, clear thinking, excellent communication skills, or high levels of software application. Accepting the willing volunteer without these attributes can be a costly mistake.
You need someone to whom you can give ‘responsibilities’ and trust them to deliver, not a person who needs simple ‘tasks’ spelling out day by day. Competence and reliability are key requirements.
4: Home rather than office
I have already made the point that there is unlikely to be a proper Church Office but it may be more sensible to think in terms of the Assistant having a home or virtual office. They will need to come to the Minister’s home from time to time but there is no real need for them to have a work base there.
Instead think in terms of how modern tech can be used to allow the Assistant to work from wherever they are. The one time they will need to come to a specific location will be to use equipment they do not have, such as a photocopier or binder.
This means of course that the Assistant owns a laptop and has a home with enough space for a work base that does not interfere too much with their personal life.
Some groups of small churches can benefit from a benefice, deanery or circuit office but, for the application I have in mind in this article, this is not a necessary feature for a Minister’s Assistant.
5: Flexible rather than fixed
This kind of appointment is unlikely to work well if the Assistant can only offer two hours each Monday and Friday morning, for example. It calls for something much more flexible than this. The benefit will only be full realised if they have enough freedom in their week to work for the Minister when needed. That is almost certain to vary week by week.
This may mean having to fit round the Minister’s diary, or being available out of office hours to phone people out at work during the day. It will imply having time available for when there is work to be done rather than the Minister having to spend their time packaging work into fixed slots during the week.
Few people can be totally flexible in this way, but the ideal would be someone who has the scope and availability to work in different patterns week by week. This kind of appointment cannot work well for an Assistant who can only offer rigid hours.
It is also unlikely to work well for very few hours in a week. Someone who can offer five or more hours a week should be fine, but the ideal might be more like eight or ten.
6: Voluntary rather than paid
The ideal would be the availability of funds to pay for such an appointment for a few hours each week, but I am going to assume this is unlikely to be the case for many Ministers of small churches. For a start the small church is unlikely to have funds to pay for an appointment of this kind, and then there is the issue of employment and all the legislation involved as well as PAYE.
It is also possible that the church would not authorise such an appointment if taken to the Church Council or equivalent, and that this needs to be more of a private arrangement between the Minister and the Assistant.
So it is likely that this will work best with a volunteer, even though that means lack of legislative control over them. But the kind of flexibility that has been suggested would make this a better way forward anyway. The post envisaged is more likely to be one of personal relationship and trust for both Minister and Assistant.
7: Limited rather than open-ended
But there is one issue where some employment restriction might be no bad idea and that concerns the length of appointment. If you have a voluntary post with very little structure around it, it can become very difficult to draw the arrangement to a close when the time comes. The difficulty will be more acute if the Minister and Assistant are, or have become, good friends in working together.
It may prove that the appointment is not working out as well as had been hoped, and either the Minister or the Assistant feel it would be better to close it down or find someone else. But if there are no guidelines designed for such a situation it might be embarrassing to talk in these terms.
Or it may be that the church grows and the model of a Parish Administrator becomes more appropriate. Again, it could be awkward to bring this arrangement to an end and then appoint a salaried Administrator.
So it might well be wise for both Minister and Administrator to agree on a fixed term appointment which can then be reviewed and renewed or brought to an end. Something of this kind for a volunteer is wise and adds a degree of discipline to what can otherwise be a very open-ended arrangement.
A final note
Well, that is all very well, you may say, but how do find this incredible, able angel who is prepared to work all hours for no pay? No, it is not easy, but here are the places to look in. In all this beware jumping at anyone who offers. The above points should have made it clear that there can be people who are not going to offer the benefit you need for this post.
- The congregation – this will be the first base for search in the hope that there may be a Christian who would see this as their area of practical service for the church. This might be someone who is retired but still full of energy with some professional organisational background. Or it could be a parent whose children are now at school with time on their hands and not needing a second salary in the family.
- The local community – it does not have to be a member of your congregation and might suit someone who is a member of another church or who has no faith as such but who is happy to work in your context and with your values. There are clear disadvantages here in that they will not meet your congregation on a Sunday and so might remain faceless. But it could work.
- A member of another local church – it may be that someone in a much larger church in a nearby suburban area or town would see this as a form of Christian service. So it would be worth promoting the need to larger churches (of all denominations) within a reasonable distance.
Before announcing this, it would be wise to produce a role description and person profile for such a post, based on what I have written above. Otherwise you lay yourself open to unsuitable offers or misunderstandings. Article A6 in the Resources section of my website will help you here – but, for a volunteer, keep it very simple.
Finally, remember that it may be worth waiting rather than appointing someone who proves unsuitable in any way. Follow my seven suggestions and I hope that you will find the right person.
JOHN Truscott is an independent church consultant and trainer who champions the ministry of creative organisation. Visit his website and check out the Resources section for a growing range of over 170 items which you can print out and/or download. You can follow John on Twitter @johnnvtruscott. Church Administrators should join the UK Church Administrators Network (UCAN) at www.churchadministrators.net